The best decision financially usually is to drive it til it dies, and view a vehicle purely as a conveyance, not a status item. I find SUVs in the main to be gas hogs without much interior room relative to a "minivan". But they clearly are far more popular.
When my kids left for college, I traded a minivan with about 88,000 miles on it for the Caddy CTS 2005 which I liked quite a bit. A more practical vehicle would have been a Malibu or Accord. The RWD struggled in the snow. My wife ended up driving it when her lease ran out for a while, she didn't like that the read end would "step out" in the rain going around a corner at times. I found a deal on a 2012 CTS with AWD, it had 4,000 miles on it, beautiful car I thought, and it was loaded.
The GTI remains my favorite car I've ever driven much, but when they hit me with a $3,000 maintenance bill at 33,000 miles, I was ... displeased. I knew it was a ripoff and I could have done better away from the dealer, but the wife wanted the CUV thingee.
I dropped her off today to go into the Post Office. You park (free) at a garage inside a building, and when she came out I got lost in the garage, took me 5 minutes to find my way out.